data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/cc5dc/cc5dcf0ce482128b8ba293ec237b3329abf69a1b" alt="Madden 08 pc buy"
Many of the motion controls work brilliantly. Madden 08 is packed full of gesture controls, most of which will be familiar to fans who played last year’s version.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c6379/c6379cdd3a73ea7e310e358a7bb906ad97455026" alt="madden 08 pc buy madden 08 pc buy"
It’s a robust package that trumps last year’s game in many ways, but also reveals some glaring issues with EA’s approach to motion-controlled football that, ultimately, make Madden NFL 08 feel a lot less engaging that it should be. Arriving a brisk 10 months later, Madden NFL 08 comes with some added control refinements, a huge increase in mini-games, a new mom-friendly "Family Play" control option, and online play. Last year’s Madden NFL 07 for Wii represented a rare breakthrough for the visceral side of the equation, offering a full suite of gesture controls to connect players to the physical side of the sport in a more direct way. For the most part, football video games have favored the strategic elements, offering a wealth of plays, audibles, and hot routes to tinker with, while settling into a comfortably chess-like perspective capturing all the action from a bird’s eye view.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/897dc/897dc975461963cf6b281cb7e24b75786a84899f" alt="madden 08 pc buy madden 08 pc buy"
Players have a dauntingly small window of time to coordinate and execute a play that will have been planned and practiced for weeks or months. The game of football is an extraordinary combination of complex tactics and intensely focused violence.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/cc5dc/cc5dcf0ce482128b8ba293ec237b3329abf69a1b" alt="Madden 08 pc buy"